|

For Greenwood Elementary School,
Nordmann installed an easily
maintained roof. |
From BUILDINGS magazine, JULY 2001
Keeping an Eye Out for Trouble
Preparedness for longer roof life
By Barbara L. Vergetis Lundin
Servicing and maintaining a roofing system is really no different
than maintaining a home, car, etc. However, many commercial rooftop
systems go unattended. The roofing system is an investment in the
building, and the better it is taken care of, the better it will
perform.
Inspections - What to Look For
It is recommended that commercial roofing systems be inspected at least
twice a year - once in the fall before winter sets in, and once in early
spring, according to Tom Gallivan, marketing manager, Stevens Roofing
Systems, Holyoke, MA.
"In addition, it's a good idea to inspect the roof
after any major weather event, as well as after the completion of any
work, such as maintenance of an air-conditioning unit," Gallivan
cautions.
During an inspection, make sure drains and scuppers are open and clear
of debris so water can be shed from the roof without interruption.
Inspect wall flashings and all sealants and caulks. These items can
break down over time, but are typically simple and inexpensive to fix.
Evaluate the overall condition of the roofing system, and answer this
key question: Is the roof in good condition overall, or are there
obvious signs of wear? Note areas of ponding water and watch them
carefully. The ideal roofing system has no ponded water 24 to 48 hours
after a rainstorm. In addition, if the roof is mechanically attached,
look at the roof's plane to make sure there is no tenting - an
indication that a fastener is backing out and creating a high spot on
the membrane.
Other questions to ask when performing a roof inspection include:
- Is there proper drainage?
- Are there conduits to drain the moisture from
air-conditioning units away from the roof?
- Are the flashing, drain, and penetration
details in good condition?
- Does the roof show signs of excessive
weathering?
- Do the roof seams have fish mouths or
openings?
Facilities professionals can enlist the help of
such professional associations as the National Roofing Contractors
Association (NRCA) and its local affiliates, the Roof Coatings
Manufacturers Association (RCMA), the Asphalt Roof Manufacturers
Association (ARMA), SPRI, and the Roof Consultants Institute (RCI).
Further, look for manufacturers with a proven record of success and
those that can offer extensive references, field support, and widespread
product availability, recommends Chris Salazar, vice president of sales
and marketing, Karnak Corp., Clark, NJ.
Maintenance - The Key to Long Life
Maintenance is the key to prolonging roof life, yet many surfaces go
unattended for years.
"A good maintenance program will help protect your investment and
prevent costly business interruption," says Gallivan. "The key to the
success of this program is implementing a regular schedule of roof
inspections that can lead to early detection of minor roof problems,
before they become major problems or cause serious damage."
Routine maintenance requires a visual inspection of all components of
the roof, according to David A. Scheirer, group market manager, Johns
Manville Roofing Systems Group, Denver. This includes below the deck,
the building exterior, the rooftop, surfaces and membranes, flashings
and penetrations, and all other components on and adjacent to the roof.
It is important to keep foot traffic to a minimum. "The more often
people are on the roof, the more often maintenance investigations should
be conducted," recommends Patrick D. McGrady, director, Technical and
Warranty Services, Carlisle Syntec Inc., Carlisle, PA.
Planned maintenance and inspections of roofing systems can significantly
extend the life-cycle of an installed roof system. "Early detection and
repair can prevent more extensive and costly repairs to problems that
fester due to lack of attention," says Scheirer.
In addition, complete, accurate records that document the dates and
details of all rooftop inspections and maintenance can provide a
valuable tool in extending a roof's life-cycle. Keep these records on
file for future reference. Easy-to-use, inexpensive CAD programs can
help. Such programs assist facilities professional in keeping detailed,
layered records of all the maintenance conducted during a roof's life -
an invaluable resource.
"This information logging process will detail who and where the
responsibilities lie pertaining to rooftop problems," explains McGrady.
Gallivan agrees, adding, "It is also advisable to take photographs of
the roof at the time of inspection, since they can serve as a reference
for the next examination or for any warranty or insurance claims. With
this data, you will not have to start from scratch every time the roof
is inspected."
Troubleshooting Tools
A number of tools are available to assist facilities professionals with
roof inspection and maintenance:
- Portable Thermal Imaging Systems. These
devices offer a picture or thermal image of the properties of the
roof. "Typically, the roof is scanned - approximately one to two
hours after sundown - and divided into grids," explains McGrady.
"Moist areas will clearly appear as the brighter areas on the
thermal camera. The brighter the image, the more moisture."
- Non-Destructive Moisture Analysis. A
non-destructive evaluation investigates moisture penetration into a
roofing assembly. Several types are available, including
capacitance, nuclear, and infrared. None of these non-destructive
test methods actually measures the presence of water. They measure
other factors that can indicate whether or not water is present.
Non-Destructive testing does not require perforation or cuts into
the roofing membrane.
- Destructive Moisture Analysis. A destructive
evaluation measures the ability of current to travel underneath the
roofing membrane from one probe to the other. The only way to truly
measure moisture content is through destructive testing. Roof cuts
do need to be made to the roofing membrane.
- Capacitance. Capacitance measures dielectric
current or the ability of roofing materials to conduct electricity.
Since water conducts electric current readily, high-capacitance
moisture meter readings could indicate the presence of water.
- Nuclear. Nuclear measures the presence of
hydrogen atoms or changes in hydrogen atom concentration at or below
a roof's surface. Water contains hydrogen. High readings on a
nuclear moisture meter could indicate the presence of water.
- Infrared. Infrared analysis measures
localized temperature differences on the roof surface. Since wet
roofing materials conduct heat more readily than dry materials, wet
areas appear in the infrared camera as higher heat loss areas.
- Aerial Infrared. Aerial infrared provides an
overview of the entire roof surface, highlighting the differences in
roof surface temperature. These temperature differences can reveal
the presence of moisture.
"It is important to note that although these
devices can provide fairly accurate information, none of these devices
measure moisture," Salazar explains. "They measure characteristics
associated with moisture, such as differences in roof temperature,
capacitance, or the presence of hydrogen. Because this information can
be misread, the information these tools provide should be further
evaluated by a certified roofing professional who can evaluate a
facilities professional's short-term, long-term, and budgeting needs to
determine a suitable and effective solution."
"The best troubleshooting tool is experience," contends Scheirer.
"A good visual inspection of a roofing system and the building can
reveal potential future problems."
Coatings
Most roofing systems, from built-up and coal tar to metal and
single-ply, can be maintained using a combination of coatings,
membranes, and sealers.
Coatings can extend roof life by performing the following functions:
- Eliminating minor surface crevices (alligatoring).
- Adding a protective layer to abuse from the
elements.
- Reducing thermal shock damage by reducing
excessive surface temperature swings.
- Affecting the interior temperature of a
building so it is more comfortable.
- Reducing energy consumption.
- Protecting ponded areas and reducing
deterioration caused by ponded water.
- Adding a protective layer to flashings and
other critical areas.
- Reducing stress levels on the supporting
structure.
SOURCE: KARNAK CORP
Inspection Checklist
Maintaining an inspection checklist provides critical documentation of
roof maintenance. Consider the following elements in your inspection:
- Support structures
Flashings
- Pitch pockets
- Caulk
- Fascia and roof edging materials
- Termination points
SOURCE: STEVENS ROOFING SYSTEMS
Maintenance Checklist
To ensure roof performance, a building owner should check the following
maintenance items regularly:
- Drainage - Drain areas should be kept clean
to prevent clogging that will result in areas of ponding water on
the roof.
- Petroleum Products - These products (greases,
solvents, oils, and liquids containing petroleum products) can
contribute to membrane degradation. "Catch pans" should be installed
in areas where these products are vented onto the roof surface.
- HVAC - This rooftop equipment must be
serviced regularly.
- Walkways should be used when moving back and
forth from these units. Exercise caution with tools and equipment to
prevent punctures in the roof surface.
- Roof Alterations - Any modifications to the
roofing system, such as the addition or removal of units, building
expansion, etc., should be promptly reported to the roofing product
manufacturer to ensure that repairs are completed utilizing
compatible materials.
- Skylights and Miscellaneous Rooftop Equipment
- When changes are made or maintenance is performed (replacing
skylight lenses, servicing exhaust fans, etc.), an approved roofing
contractor should be contacted to ensure detail compliance with
flashings, etc. Metal shavings, screws, nails, etc., can andm do
cause damage to roofing systems, resulting in leaks.
SOURCE: CARLISLE SYNTEC INC. |